solution-architecture

Solution Architecture Elements

Solution architecture generally encompasses a high-level view of both software and systems engineering, along with considerations for requirements. Leveraging extensive project experience, these elements are categorized into three groups to comprehensively cover the solution architecture. Instead of a lengthy narrative, I present the key components in a simple list as well as an easy-to-understand visual format.

Solution architecture also involves solution architecture management (budget, resource, timeline, deliverable phase), which serves as a context for the solution architecture. This page focuses on the content or the core of the solution architecture.

Solution Architecture Element List

Here is a very brief list of the solution architecture elements. For more detailed information about the element definitions and their relationship to the Enterprise Solution Architecture (ESA), refer to this link.

Category Element Prefix Implication Base Mapping
Intent/Metrics User RO Stakeholder, Actor Role
Intent/Metrics Task TK Activity, Event Task
Intent/Metrics Requirement RQ Intent, Non-functional Requirement Requirement
Intent/Metrics Decision KC Key Consideration, Governance Key Choice
Intent/Metrics Artifact AR Documentation, Repository, Code Artifact
Intent/Metrics Service GS Domain, Use Case Generic Service, Service Definition
Functional/Application Application AP ERP App Application
Functional/Application AI Agent AG AI Bot Agent
Functional/Application User Interface UI CLI, UI User/Access Interface
Functional/Application Process PS Flow, Lifecycle Process
Functional/Application App Controller AS AI Coordinator App Logic Service
Functional/Application Data Module DS Knowledge Access Data Service
Functional/Application AI Model ML LLM Data Service
Functional/Application Context CN State, Memory Data Service
Functional/Application API Interface SC   Service Interface
Functional/Application Utility Service TS Tool Tech Service
Functional/Application Component SC Object, Module Service Component
Functional/Application Microservice MS Self-contained Unit Deployment Package
Operational/Middleware Frontend FE Mobile Device, PC Device UI Service, Middleware
Operational/Middleware System SY System Device System
Operational/Middleware Database DB Storage Data Store
Operational/Middleware Deployment Unit DP   Deployment Package
Operational/Middleware Node ND Server Node
Operational/Middleware Service Broker SB Message Broker, Event Broker Middleware
Operational/Middleware Message/Event MG   Data Service, Tech Service, Middleware
Operational/Middleware Monitoring GO Governance Control, Analytics, Observability,  Quality & Adaptation Middleware, Governance
Operational/Middleware Gateway GW API Gateway, Router Middleware
Operational/Middleware Security FI Security Threat, Virus Preventation Firewall Middleware
Operational/Middleware Caching CA CDN Middleware
Operational/Middleware Cloud CL Cloud Service, Cloud Platform Domain, Location

Iconic Notation Representation

Here is the representation of a list of elements using visual icon images in an easily understandable format.

Intent & Metric Elements

Figure 1 shows the intent and metrics layer elements. The yellowish color represents the user end, white represents business considerations and design decisions, and the light purple color represents the key metrics, including quality attributes, architectural decisions, and governance controls.

User Intent Elements

Figure 1. User Intent Elements

Functional/Application Elements

Figure 2 shows a list of application-level elements. These are the critical functional service-level elements, each of which needs to be carefully considered. For AI solutions, AI-specific elements should also be included. The components are also related to software design and are either high-level or used for walkthroughs for validation purposes. The microservice elements are partially operational considerations.

Functional/Application Elements

Figure 2. Functional/Application Elements

Operational/Middleware Elements

Figure 3 shows a list of operational/middleware elements. The bluish elements represent middleware, whereas the gray elements represent the operational infrastructure level.

Operational/Middleware Elements

Figure 3. Operational/Middleware Elements

Key Architectural Concerns

With a well-defined set of solution architecture elements, we can facilitate architectural modeling by thinking through these elements to see how they are considered, mapped, and guided. For a sound architecture, we need to look beyond technical details or specifications and focus on the architectural concerns that are significant to the solution.

Summary

Architectural modeling is not just about diagramming; it is a thinking process. Think through all the core solution elements, place them in your view to apply architectural techniques and identify their correlations. Through iteration and regular review, reach and maintain an architectural model that is holistic and rooted in simplicity and significance. A solution covers both intent and architectural concerns, both software and system architectures, and both implicit enterprise input and explicit design guidance output. As part of ESA (enterprise solution architecture), it plays an increasingly important role in the AI era, when enterprise planning and solution design details are increasingly handled by AI.

Reference Source